The 14 Cheesiest Eats in Chicago | UrbanMatter
HomeRestaurantsThe 14 Cheesiest Eats in Chicago

The 14 Cheesiest Eats in Chicago

Cheesiest Food Chicago

The 14 Cheesiest Eats in Chicago

MATURE CONTENT WARNING: The following article has been rated Internet-MA for using downright obscene pictures of the cheesiest eats in Chicago.

Enter at your own risk.

These are the 14 best cheese-filled foods in the city.

 

Mac & Cheese @ Hot Chocolate

Wicker Park

Bakery kween and my own personal hero, Mindy Segal, may be best known for her pastries, chocolates, and overall sugary goodness. But hidden in plain sight at her Wicker Park mainstay, Hot Chocolate, is some of –if not THE – best mac & cheese in Chicago. Ooey, gooey and served to perfection, is there anything a cheese lover could crave more?

Price: $13

 

The Mac @ Cheesie’s

Cheesiest Eats in Chicago

Photo Credit: Cheesie’s Instagram

Multiple Locations

As the drunk-food-of-choice for many a north side Chicagoan, I bet you kinda knew that Cheesie’s would make an appearance somewhere on this list. I mean, the place is called Cheesie’s, after all.

And though, as you might imagine, it was pretty hard to pick just one grilled cheese off of their all-star menu, we just couldn’t give it up to anything other than The Mac: an IG worthy blend of American cheese, Merkt’s cheddar cheese, and homemade macaroni and cheese served on Texas toast. (Don’t worry, Tenderizer, I still love you.)

Price: $7.99

 

Fondue @ Punch House

Cheesiest Food in Chicago

Photo Credit: Punch House IG

Pilsen

This little gem hidden underneath Thalia Hall has fully embraced its 70’s vibe, serving up bomb-ass drinks in crystal punch bowls and, yes, amazing fondue. And though you might be inclined to bring a few friends along to down this delectably-cheesy shareable snack, I promise you that you’re gonna wanna hog it all to yourself. And maybe lick the bowl, too.

What? Don’t judge me.

Price: $25

 

The Juicy Lucy @ Dusek’s

Cheesiest Food Chicago

Photo Credit: Dusek’s IG

Pilsen

Known the city over as one of the best damn burgers in Chicago, Dusek’s Juicy Lucy just so happens to also be one of the cheesiest. Made with Slagel Farms beef, stuffed with American cheese, topped with red onion bacon marmalade, heirloom tomato, butter lettuce, a brioche bun, and served with beef fat frites, this all-American classic LITERALLY bleeds cheese. Amazing.

Price: $15

 

Pizza Pot Pie @ Chicago Pizza & Oven Grinder Co.

Lincoln Park

I think I speak for us all when I say, CHEEEEEEESEEEEEE.

The pizza pot pie at Chicago Pizza & Oven Griner Co. isn’t just hella famous, it’s also delicious. Need I say more?

Price: $25.50

 

Mac & Cheese @ Frontier

Cheesiest Food Chicago

Photo Credit: Frontier Instagram

West Town

You may go to Frontier for their whole animal service (anyone else down to eat a whole gator?) but you will stay at Frontier for the mac and cheese. A hearty 5-cheese covered macaroni with serious cheese-pull potential, this side dish steals the damn show.

Price: $9

 

Queso Fundido @ Big Star

Cheesiest Food in Chicago

Photo Credit: Big Star Instagram

Multiple Locations

Sure, Big Star’s got a lot going for them: great tacos, killer margaritas, and a honky-tonk vibe that just won’t quit? Who wouldn’t wanna spend a summer afternoon pigging out on their porch? But if there’s one dish on either of Big Star’s menus the instantly make us start drooling, it’s the queso fundido.

Move over, nacho cheese – you’ve been dethroned.

Price: $9

 

Fondue @ Geja’s Cafe

Cheesiest Food in Chicago

Photo Credit: Geja’s Cafe IG

Lincoln Park

Geja’s Cafe in Lincoln Park has got to be one of the most romantic restaurants this side of the Loop. But when you’re not making eyes at bae, you’re most likely stuffing your face full of their cheese-alicious fondue.

Price: $16.95

 

Saganaki @ Greek Islands

Greek Town

A true Chicago classic, this flaming cheese appetizer was invented in the Second City. And though, no, the original restaurant responsible for bringing this glorious bit of cheesy goodness to our table is no longer in businesses, Greek Islands makes a pretty fantastic rendition if I don’t say so myself.

Price: $5.95

 

Mac & Cheese @ SKL

Cheesiest Food Chicago

Photo Credit: Scratch Kitchen

Multiple Locations

The mac at Scratch Kitchen and Lounge in Oak Park is great, there’s no doubt about it. But add to that the fact that each skillet of gooey-greatness is completely customizable with toppings like buffalo chicken, truffle parmesan, or pulled pork and, come on, there’s no way you could resist.

Price: $14.50 – $16.50

 

French Onion Soup @ Le Bouchon

Cheesiest Foods in Chicago

Photo Credit: Le Bouchon Instagram

Wicker Park

Everyone knows that the best part of French onion soup is the cheese lid on top. This is purely a fact. And Le Bouchon in Wicker Park makes the best French onion soup around town. Hands down.

Price: $11

 

Mozzarella Sticks @ Roots

Cheesiest Foods in Chicago

Photo Credit: Roots Instagram

Multiple Locations

Sure, Roots pizza is great! But it wouldn’t be a proper trip to this Chicago favorite without an order of their ~award winning~ mozzarella sticks. I mean, just look at that photo! Fried to perfection and served with a side a marinara, I could easily put back a full plate. Or two. Or three.

Price: $11

 

The Cheese Plate @ Bar Pastoral

Cheesiest Food in Chicago

Photo Credit: Yelp

Lakeview

Owned and operated by the fine folks at Pastoral Bread, Wine, and Cheese, the cheese plate at Bar Pastoral might not have the same finger-licking appeal as some of the other spots on this list. No, the draw of this cheesiest eat is purely in the quality of the cheese itself. Sure, American and Provolone are great, but even cheese lovers can appreciate the finer things in life sometimes, right?

Price: Dependent on Market Prices

 

Just, like Giordano’s, in General

Multiple Locations

To quote a really angry comment from our pizza roundup “real Chicago pizza isn’t a bowl of dough!!!”

Except yes, it is. And it’s totally effing awesome.

 

 

Featured Image Credit: Chicago Pizza and Oven Grinder Co. Instagram 

Share With:
Rate This Article

As an avid NPR listener and self-described Snapchat addict, Jessica Hamrick is excited to showcase her love for all things media as an Editor at UrbanMatter. Her short-yet-illustrious academic career was dedicated to finding the intersections between writing and marketing and she’s definitely found it here. In her free time, Jessica can be found hanging out with her dog Indie, watching the Food Network or commiserating with fellow, unfortunate White Sox fans.

jhamrick@urbanmatter.com

No Comments

Leave A Comment