Table of Contents
In the world of psychiatric care, ensuring the safety and well-being of patients is often purported as the primary goal. However, the grim reality portrayed by the regularity of wrongful death cases in mental health treatment facilities continues to unveil systemic failures and regulatory challenges that cannot be overlooked. While these cases certainly demand accountability and reform, they also compel us to question the fundamental principles underlying psychiatric care and its commitment to coercion and force, rather than genuine healing and support.
Wrongful Death in California
One case that highlights this particular issue is the death of Lonnie Rupard at the San Diego County Jail in 2022. Lonnie was a 47-year-old man suffering from schizophrenia who tragically passed away in his cell. His death, which was ruled a homicide by the San Diego County Medical Examiner, was attributed to pneumonia, malnutrition, and dehydration exacerbated by neglected schizophrenia. Despite following traffic laws while crossing the street, Lonnie was struck by a car, leading to his arrest and subsequent mistreatment in custody. His family filed a wrongful death lawsuit against the San Diego County Sheriff’s Department and medical agencies servicing the jails. They allege negligence and deliberate indifference in Lonnie’s care.
Cases
In another California case, Brandon Nelson committed suicide at a Sovereign Health treatment facility in San Clemente in 2018. Brandon was a 26-year-old aerospace engineer who suffered a psychotic break and tragically hung himself at the mental health facility. The response from the staff is where negligence comes into play, with staff members struggling to properly respond with CPR or even provide an address to emergency responders. Nelson’s family ultimately settled for $11 million after suing Sovereign and its CEO for the wrongful death of their son, who was promised 24/7 psychiatric services upon entering the facility.
As recently as February 2024, a new case has occurred. San Diego County’s sheriff and various healthcare contractors are being sued by yet another family whose loved one died in a California jail. Matthew Settles, who had a long documented history of mental illness and disabilities, took his own life in an Otay Mesa jail. No staff members were ensuring that Mattew was taking his prescribed medication, and he was left in isolation for four weeks while suffering mentally. His schizoaffective disorder was allegedly ignored and he was left all alone without care, cites the lawsuit. This negligence occurred despite a 2018 report that warned the San Diego Sheriff’s Department about the negative effects of isolation on mental illness.
These three cases, among countless others, serve as harrowing reminders of the inherent flaws within the psychiatric care system. The use of force, rather than compassion and support, often characterizes the approach to mental health treatment, resulting in tragic outcomes that are all too common. The pervasive culture of control and domination within psychiatric facilities not only undermines the autonomy and dignity of patients but also perpetuates a cycle of harm and suffering that is antithetical to the principles of healing and recovery.
Challenging the System
It is imperative that we confront these uncomfortable truths and challenge the status quo in psychiatric care. Merely addressing surface-level issues such as understaffing and inadequate training is insufficient; we must interrogate the very foundations of the psychiatric system and its reliance on coercive practices that undermine the agency and well-being of those it purports to serve. Only by centering the voices of individuals with lived experience, and prioritizing genuine empathy and compassion, can we hope to cultivate a mental health care system that is truly humane, equitable, and just.
The pervasive culture of control within psychiatric facilities undermines the principles of healing and recovery. To truly address these issues, we must go beyond surface-level fixes and interrogate the very foundations of psychiatric care.
Central to reforming the mental health care system is centering the voices of individuals with lived experience. Their insights and perspectives are invaluable in shaping policies and practices that prioritize empathy, compassion, and respect for human dignity. Additionally, there must be a concerted effort to challenge the prevailing culture of coercion and force, replacing it with a more humane and equitable approach to care.
The Steep Path to Reform
Accountability and transparency are also critical components of reform. Wrongful death cases must be thoroughly investigated, and those responsible for negligence or misconduct must be held accountable. Additionally, below are further suggestions for reform in the mental healthcare system.
Promoting Alternatives to Incarceration: In the case of Lonnie Rupard, did he even need to be in jail? Or was he an innocent man who suffered from a mental illness? One step in the right direction would be to divert individuals with mental illness away from the criminal justice system and into community-based mental health programs and supportive services. This involves implementing diversion programs, specialized courts (e.g., mental health courts), and crisis intervention training for law enforcement officers to ensure that individuals receive appropriate care rather than incarceration.
Investment in Community-Based Care: Prioritize funding and resources for community-based mental health services. This includes expanding access to outpatient clinics, crisis intervention teams, peer support programs, and supportive housing. Community-based care allows for early intervention, personalized treatment plans, and ongoing support, reducing the need for hospitalization and institutionalization.
- Integration of Mental Health and Primary Care: Integrate mental health services into primary care settings to ensure holistic and coordinated care. This can involve training primary care providers in mental health screening, assessment, and treatment, as well as establishing collaborative care models where mental health professionals work alongside medical doctors to address both physical and mental health needs.
- Expansion of Telehealth Services: Expand access to telehealth services for mental health care, particularly in rural and underserved areas. Telehealth allows individuals to receive counseling, therapy, and psychiatric consultations remotely, overcoming barriers such as geographic distance, transportation issues, and stigma associated with seeking in-person care.
- Enhanced Training and Education: Improve training and education for mental health professionals, including psychiatrists, psychologists, social workers, and counselors. This includes incorporating cultural competency, trauma-informed care, and evidence-based practices into curricula. Additionally, ongoing professional development and supervision are essential to ensure quality and competence in delivering care.
- Regulation and Oversight of Treatment Facilities: Implement stricter regulations and oversight mechanisms for mental health treatment facilities, including both public and private settings. This involves establishing minimum standards for staffing, qualifications, safety protocols, and treatment modalities. Regular inspections, licensing requirements, and transparent reporting of outcomes are necessary to ensure compliance and accountability.
- Strengthening Crisis Intervention Services: Invest in crisis intervention services to provide timely and appropriate support to individuals experiencing mental health crises. This includes establishing crisis hotlines, mobile crisis teams, and crisis stabilization centers where individuals can receive immediate assessment, de-escalation, and connection to follow-up care.
- Prevention and Early Intervention Programs: Prioritize prevention and early intervention programs aimed at addressing risk factors and promoting mental well-being from a young age. This includes school-based mental health education, screening programs, parenting support initiatives, and community outreach efforts to reduce stigma and increase awareness of mental health issues.
As we grapple with the devastating consequences of wrongful death cases in psychiatric care settings, we must recognize that these tragedies are not isolated incidents but rather symptomatic of a broader malaise within the system itself. It is incumbent upon us to demand accountability, transparency, and systemic reform that upholds the inherent dignity and worth of every individual, regardless of their mental health status. Only then can we begin to honor the memories of those we have lost and ensure that their deaths were not in vain.