Table of Contents
This story contains details of alleged sexual offenses that some readers may find distressing.
The 2023 Channel 4 documentary about Russell Brand “poisoned the well of justice deliberately” and “fundamentally corrupted” his accusers, according to the closing defense argument of Brand’s lawyer.
Ian Winter leaned on a phrase, coined by a mid-19th century Catholic philosopher, to argue that the Dispatches film, plus reporting in The Times, were responsible for six women coming forward to police with allegations about the Despicable Me star from two decades prior.
Making his closing argument at London’s Southwark Crown Court before the jury is sent away to reach a verdict, Winter was heavily critical of the journalists behind the reporting.
Russell Brand’s Lawyer Questioned How The Channel 4 Documentary Was Made
Winter also criticised the production of the 2023 Channel 4 documentary, describing it as one-sided and dramatically presented.
He took issue with the use of actors portraying anonymous women who made allegations against Brand, arguing that the programme’s presentation could influence viewers before the claims had been tested in court.
The defence lawyer also questioned the journalists’ methods, alleging that they had covertly recorded women they spoke to and used disappearing WhatsApp messages during their conversations.
Winter further complained that Brand had not been properly interviewed during the documentary’s production, apart from being approached for a right of reply.
He used these criticisms to support his wider argument that the programme had influenced the way the subsequent case against him developed.
“They poisoned the well of justice deliberately to bring about a prosecution of Mr Brand for sexual assault and for rape,” the barrister said.
“And they did so not in respect of any single one of the complaints that were in the heart of the [Channel 4] programme, who were anonymous and who were not prepared to put their names to those allegations.
They poisoned the well in the hope and intention that other people would come forward and make allegations against him.”
Russell Brand’s Lawyer Argued His Behaviour Did Not Suggest Guilt
Winter also challenged the prosecution’s interpretation of how Brand behaved following the alleged incidents. He told jurors that the women had described him behaving normally during or after some of the encounters, which he argued was inconsistent with the allegations.
The barrister suggested that Russell Brand’s behaviour showed he genuinely believed the sexual encounters had been consensual. He also pointed to the first complainant’s account of Brand leaving his email address and photographs behind after their alleged encounter in Bournemouth in 1999.
Winter questioned why someone guilty of rape would behave in that manner, arguing that Brand had no reason to believe he had done anything wrong.
He told the jury that Brand was not someone who committed rape while believing his actions were normal. The defence maintained that Brand believed the women had consented to what happened.
The six accusers therefore came forward “not because they themselves determined to do so independently of anything else, but each one was exposed to the poison they had seen in the TV programme,” Winter said.
Winter said the documentary had also “poisoned the well” and had a “truly devastating effect” on Brand, pointing to his evidence when he said he had been banned from visiting his son in hospital after the film aired.
“It caused people to shun Russell Brand’s, to positively wish him ill before his trial took place, and to refuse to stand by him or give evidence for him,” said Winter.
Winter continued returning to the “poisoning of the well” argument as his defense of each allegation was made. He went through each of the complainants, who have a lifelong right to anonymity, and noted how he believed they had been influenced by the film.
Winter Said Brand Accepted The Woman’s Refusal During The Alleged MTV Incident
Winter also addressed the allegation involving the second complainant, who says Brand attempted to drag her into a men’s toilet at MTV in 2001.
The defence argued that although Brand had been behaving aggressively and persistently, he eventually accepted the woman’s refusal when she made it clear she did not want to go inside.
Winter challenged the prosecution’s presentation of the encounter, particularly its use of a 20-second period of silence during the closing argument to illustrate how long the woman said she had struggled against him.
He told jurors that the encounter had not actually been silent, claiming Brand had been pleading with her to enter the toilet rather than physically forcing her inside.
Winter suggested that the woman now genuinely believed she would have been assaulted if she had entered the bathroom, but argued that this did not establish that Russell Brand had attempted to assault her.
He said many accusers in the trial had “never told a soul” until after the doc came out while one was imposing “2023’s thinking, not 2001’s” when the incident is alleged to have taken place.
Complainant 5, who alleges Brand anally raped her after they had consensual sex, “had told lots of people different stories over the years,” added Winter.
“But it wasn’t until she saw the programme that she said, ‘I know personally from watching it that it was the first time I truly felt a monumental change.’ One wonders what her evidence would have been if she had not seen [the documentary]?,” he questioned.

Defence Pointed To A Contact Saved In Russell Brand’s Phone
Another detail raised during Winter’s closing argument concerned the fifth complainant, who alleges Brand raped her anally at his Hampstead home in 2009.
The court had previously heard that her telephone number was found in Brand’s phone in 2012 under the name “T AP **”. During his evidence, Brand explained that the letters stood for “tart” and “anal play”, while the asterisks marked an interaction he did not want to forget.
Winter challenged the prosecution’s suggestion that the contact information had been fabricated. He argued that the number would not have been saved in Brand’s phone in that manner unless the woman had given it to him.
The defence used the contact entry to challenge the prosecution’s interpretation of their relationship and the events surrounding the alleged incident.
Winter said there is “rank unfairness” that Brand has had to “litigate something so long after the event,” which he described as “litigating in a quagmire of doubt and recollection.”
Russell Brand faces three charges of rape, three counts of sexual assault and one of attempted indecent assault, reduced from indecent assault, based on allegations made by six women, all of which he denies. Deadline has been reporting daily from a live video feed of the courtroom since the trial began.
Defence Questioned The First Complainant’s Recollection Of The 1999 Incident
Winter also focused on the first complainant, who alleges Brand raped her in Bournemouth in 1999 after they met during a fringe event at the Labour Party Conference.
On the defence point regarding her memory of what occurred and the fact that she could not give an exact date when it happened, Winter pointed out that the witness had stated she could not remember if it was Wednesday, Thursday or Friday. This meant she could not be trusted to give an accurate account.
He also challenged evidence from her former flatmate, Mark Pinheiro, who had described Brand as acting strangely the morning after the alleged incident. Pinheiro told the court that Brand appeared to be ducking and diving when police sirens could be heard.
Winter disputed that interpretation, arguing that Brand had not been running away and would simply have needed to leave the accommodation by 10 a.m.
The defence also argued that the complainant had invited Brand back and consented to sex. Winter urged the jury to conclude that there was no evidential basis to find him guilty of the alleged rape.
Russell Brand’s Defence Claimed The Documentary Influenced All Six Complainants
Winter argued that each accuser has been “contaminated by the programme” and the “very existence of them as complainants, let alone what they have actually now said, is fundamentally corrupted by that programme and publicity, and renders it fundamentally unfair.”
The prosecution has also referenced the documentary, but argued last week it was not a “magic force” that caused six separate women to “recast” their memories.
But Winter said the prosecution does not have a “case thesis” as to why he allegedly raped and assaulted these women compared to the hundreds of others that Russell Brand had consensual sex with between 1999 and 2009.
Late last week, the judge in the case urged the jury to ignore the doc, adding: “Do not think that a few women making anonymous complaints in a TV show adds any support at all to the prosecution.”

Prosecutor Said The Six Women Had Nothing To Gain By Coming Forward
During her closing argument, prosecutor Riel Karmy-Jones KC urged the jury to consider that the six women did not know one another and had not come forward seeking publicity or attention.
She argued that the women had no obvious benefit to gain from making their allegations, apart from possibly finding some closure after keeping their experiences to themselves for years.
Karmy-Jones also highlighted what she described as similarities in the women’s accounts. She told jurors that several described Brand initially being charming and flirtatious before his behaviour allegedly changed when they resisted his advances.
The prosecutor rejected the suggestion that the 2023 documentary had caused the women to invent or reshape their accounts. She maintained that the jury should assess the individual evidence rather than assume the women had been influenced into making allegations.
She ultimately invited the jury to find Brand guilty of all seven charges.
“The best [the prosecution] has been able to do is say that he was manipulating and calculating and wanted to bed a very large number of women, possibly 5,000,” said Winter.
“So what? We know that. That is the given. He devoted himself for many years to a highly promiscuous life. That is not a case as to why he raped these ones. Being flirty and telling women what they want and being manipulative in pursuit of consensual sex is completely lawful and this case had nothing to do with that.”
Russell Brand’s Lawyer Argued His Behaviour Did Not Suggest Guilt
Winter also challenged the prosecution’s interpretation of how Brand behaved following the alleged incidents. He told jurors that the women had described him behaving normally during or after some of the encounters, which he argued was inconsistent with the allegations.
The barrister suggested that Brand’s behaviour showed he genuinely believed the sexual encounters had been consensual. He also pointed to the first complainant’s account of Brand leaving his email address and photographs behind after their alleged encounter in Bournemouth in 1999.
Winter questioned why someone guilty of rape would behave in that manner, arguing that Brand had no reason to believe he had done anything wrong.
He told the jury that Brand was not someone who committed rape while believing his actions were normal. The defence maintained that Brand believed the women had consented to what happened.
The jury were reminded that the burden of proof lies squarely on the prosecution. No need to prove his innocence, but that the evidence goes to prove his guilt beyond reasonable doubt.
The defence is expected to conclude its closing arguments before the judge gives the jury legal directions. The jurors will then be sent out to consider their verdicts. Russell Brand denies all seven charges.